When Napoleon Boneabit uttered those words to his troops, at Stamford Bridge, when playing Chelsea away, few could argue with his unassailable logic. These days it seems that he could have picked on the wrong group.
Should discriminating against someone for being fat be made a hate crime?
A group of campaigners have held a demonstration outside the Mayor of London's offices, calling for him to back legislation which would make discrimination against overweight people a hate crime, on a par with racism, ageism and religious discrimination.Really? A hate crime? One of the stupidest concepts that has been written in to the statute books and you want to extend that to cover people picking on you a bit because you're fat?
Well on the plus side it will highlight how downright wrong the theory of hate crime is. Two men of the same race have a fight and the aggressor is charged with assault, ABH, GBH or a combination thereof. Sometimes they're even prosecuted but don't count on it; the Crown Prosecution Service are gutless and inept.
Good. Crime and punishment match.
Two men of differing ethnicity have a fight and the aggressor is charged with a hate crime on top of the above.
Why? It's exactly the same crime.Being nasty to someone because of their size is a bit removed from kicking seven shades out of someone because they worship the
wrong god or come from the
wrong country. Would it be a classed as a hate crime for battering a West Bromich Albion fan or just pest control? Anyway, it's the same crime, the only difference then becomes the mitigation/motive but that's part of the way judgement should work.
Been turned down for a job that you were the best candidate for (and weren't a completely unlikable interviewee) on the grounds of race, religion, size or gender? Discrimination.
Been turned down for a job because you're fat and it wouldn't effect your job performance? Not a hate crime. Just discrimination.
Discussing the issue are two campaigners and members of the Size Acceptance Movement, Kathryn Szrodecki and Marsha Coupe. Both have suffered abuse as a result of their size. Kathryn has filmed a documentary in San Francisco looking at the laws in place to protect overweight people against abuse and prejudice, and is desperate to see these laws put in place in the UK.
[...]
American-born Marsha has also learnt to deal with daily abuse because of her size. She says: "As an overweight person you get used to the daily stares and nasty comments of the general public. There is a huge hostility in the UK against fat people, much more so than in the USA, where I lived until 2005.”Right. So as opposed to saying sod this, I'm going back to the states where I'd be welcome I'm going to try and force the legislature of a foreign country to do things how I want them done. Well for a start you can do one.
Kathryn says: "In San Francisco, fat-ism is treated with the same contempt and punished in the same way as racism, ageism and religious discrimination. Laws have been passed so overweight people have equal rights." The legislation in San Francisco even governs the guidelines given to doctors as to how they should speak to their overweight patients.
Kathryn adds: "Making fatism a hate crime gives it the gravitas it deserves and allows an appropriate punishment to be enforced."The legislation goes a bit too far by half in San Francisco then. Overweight people have equal rights? Since when were they second class citizens? Where was it enshrined in law that Fat people must be discriminated against? You don't want equal rights, you want
more rights even down to the ways your doctors have to tip-toe around you.
To show how daft this idea is the protesters couldn't even protest correctly:
Yesterday’s demonstration outside the Mayor of London's office did not go quite to plan as the campaigners lacked the required permit. Kathryn says: "We will definitely be going back after we have all the paperwork we need." While demonstrating Kathryn took along her 'Yay Scales' , a set of modified scales that show the user a compliment instead of their weight. Kathryn says: "These went down a storm with the public!"Have you every heard such a contemptible idea?
Yay scales? It doesn't matter what your weight is the gayest bathroom accessory since the pink shower cap gives you a compliment. That rates an eight on the
Jesus-Wept-O-Meter and no mistake. Oh, and having to have paperwork to protest. That's a load of male bovine effluent too.
I don't like bullying. It may sound like I'm bullying these people and being fattist. I'm not fattist. They are...
Jimmy Carr #94. Bullying breaks the most sacred tenet that I believe in:
DO NO HARM.
I'm not picking holes in their argument because they're fat. I'm picking holes because it's stupid and it seeks to impose.
Your weight is your issue. If you don't like it change it, don't seek to change others around you. If you can't change it then live with it.
Don't take this the wrong way but for Christ sake, grow up.
The law is an ass and this clamouring to wear the badge
"VICTIM" seeks to make it it even more so.